Scientific Rating

CVS Nourishing Moisture Shampoo

Rank: 742 out of 2,477 shampoos · Company: CVS Pharmacy, Inc.

5.0

Health

This product contains four or more ingredients that raise a low level of health concern.

?

✔

5.0

Human Health Impacts [-]
- ?
  
  ✔
  
  8.0
  
  Other Negative Aspects [+]
  - ?
    
    ✔
    
    8.0
    
    Regulatory Status of Ingredients [-]
    Use Restriction
    
    Phenoxyethanol
- ?
  
  ✔
  
  6.0
  
  Ingredient Disclosure [+]
  - ?
    
    ✔
    
    6.0
    
    Adequacy of Ingredient Disclosure
- ?
  
  ✔
  
  5.0
  
  Level of Health Concern of Ingredients [-]
  Low Concern
  
  (1-METHYLETHYL)BENZENESULFONIC Acid,
  Sodium Salt
  
  Cocamidopropyl Betaine
  
  Phenoxyethanol
  
  Mica
  
  Titanium Dioxide
  
  Sodium Hydroxide

5.6

Environment

?

✔

5.6

Core Company Environmental Performance [-]
- ?
  
  ✔
  
  6.1
  
  Resource Use [+]
  - ?
    
    ✔
    
    7.5
    
    Energy [+]
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      8.0
      
      Energy Use per $ Revenue
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      7.0
      
      Policies and Practices [+]
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        7.0
        
        Energy Efficiency Targets
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Initiatives to Reduce Employee Transportation Impacts
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Use of Renewable Energy
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Discloses Energy Conservaton Results
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Energy Efficiency Initiatives
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Energy Efficiency Processes
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        5.0
        
        Climate Change Policy Addresses Energy Use or Conservation
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        5.0
        
        Energy Efficiency Policy
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        5.0
        
        Environmental Policy Addresses Energy Use or Conservation
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Energy Conservation Results at Non-US Facilities
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Renewable Energy Use at Non-US Facilities
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Promotes Mass Transit
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Energy Use at Non-US Facilities
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Non-renewable Energy Percentage
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Total Energy Use
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Normalized Energy Use
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Renewable Energy Percentage
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Use of Key Performance Indicators to Monitor Energy Use
  - ?
    
    ✔
    
    6.0
    
    Materials [+]
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      6.0
      
      Policies and Practices [+]
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Sustainable Packaging Processes
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Consumer Product Recycling Program
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        5.0
        
        Sustainable Packaging Policy
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        5.0
        
        Environmental Criteria Used to Source Materials
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Use of Recycled Paper in Products
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Use of Recycled Material in Products
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Use of Key Performance Indicators to Monitor Sustainable Packaging
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Dematerialization Policy
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Sustainable Packaging Targets
  - ?
    
    ✔
    
    6.0
    
    Resource Management [+]
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      6.0
      
      Processes to Improve Resource Efficiency
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      5.0
      
      Policy Addresses Resource Efficiency
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      4.0
      
      Use of Key Performance Indicators to Monitor Resource Efficiency
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      4.0
      
      Resource Efficiency Targets
  - ?
    
    ✔
    
    5.0
    
    Water [+]
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      5.0
      
      Policies and Practices [+]
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        5.0
        
        Climate Change Policy Addresses Water Use or Conservation
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Water Conserved
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Water Use at Non-US Facilities
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Water Efficiency Processes
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Policies to Improve Efficiency of Water Use
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Water Recycling Initiatives
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Normalized Water Use
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Water Efficiency Targets
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Water Conserved at Non-US Facilitities
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Total Water Use
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Environmental Policy Addresses Water Use or Conservation
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Water Recycling Program
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Use of Key Performance Indicators to Monitor Water Use
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Water Recycling Percentage
- ?
  
  ✔
  
  5.9
  
  Environmental Management [+]
  - ?
    
    ✔
    
    8.0
    
    Leading Edge Practices [+]
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      7.0
      
      Organic Product Initiatives
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      7.0
      
      Life Cycle Assessment Policies
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      6.0
      
      Green Products
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      6.0
      
      Green Products
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      6.0
      
      Green Buildings
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      6.0
      
      Initiatives to Reduce Product Transportation Impacts
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      6.0
      
      Green Product Innovation Processes
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      6.0
      
      Eco Design Policies
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      6.0
      
      LEED Certified Green Buildings
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      6.0
      
      Green Product Features
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      6.0
      
      Green Product Innovation Policies
  - ?
    
    ✔
    
    6.4
    
    Governance [+]
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      7.0
      
      Supply Chain [+]
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        7.0
        
        Use of Environmental Criteria to Select Suppliers
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Climate Change Policy Addresses Suppliers
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Policies to Reduce Environmental Impact of Supply Chain
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Supply Chain Targets
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Environmental Policy Addresses Suppliers
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Applies its Environmental Standards to Suppliers
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Progress towards Supply Chain Targets
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Use of Key Performance Indicators to Monitor Supply Chain
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Subjects Suppliers to its Climate Change Policy
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Willingness to End Partnership with Supplier for Environmental Reasons
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      6.0
      
      Reporting [+]
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Follows Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) Guidelines
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Discloses Information on Corporate Social Responsibility
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Publishes Report Covering Corporate Social Responsbility
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Publishes Report Covering Corporate Social Responsbility Following GRI Guidelines
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        5.0
        
        Climate Change Policy Includes Public Reporting
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Environmental Policy Includes Public Reporting
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Publicly Releases Data Submitted to Carbon Disclosure Project (CDP5)
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Corporate Social Responsibility Report Based on non-GRI Standard
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Top Suppliers
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Integrated Reporting Challenges
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Integrates Financial with Environmental, Social & Governance Issues in Annual Report
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Level of Coverage of GRI Issues
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        External Audit of Corporate Social Responsibility Report
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Publicly Releases Data Submitted to Carbon Disclosure Project (CDP6)
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      6.0
      
      Policies [+]
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Board Responsibility for Climate Change Policy
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Environmental Training
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Internal Communication Tools to Improve Environment Management
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Environmental Restoration Initiatives
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Environmental Management Team
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Senior Officer Responsbile for Climate Policy Implementation
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Discloses Environmental Management System
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        5.0
        
        Environmental Policy Applicable to All Operations
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        5.0
        
        Enterprise Level Environmental Policy
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Environmental Management System Processes
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Senior Officer Responsbile for Environmental Policy Implementation
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Environmental Policy Includes Quantifiable Targets
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Environmental Policy Includes Auditing
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Targets Related to Financial Performance on ESG Initiatives
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Environmental Management System Policy
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Environmental Policy Includes 3rd Party Auditing
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Use of Key Performance Indicators to Monitor Environmental Management System
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Environmental Policy Includes Stakeholder Involvement
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Environmental Investment Initiatives
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Environmental Management System Targets
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Board Responsibility for Environmental Policy
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Environmental Management System Based on ISO 14001 but Not Certified
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Specificity in Environmental Policy
  - ?
    
    ✔
    
    4.0
    
    Compliance and Controversies [+]
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      4.0
      
      Spills and Other Pollution Controversies
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      4.0
      
      Discloses Environmental Violations
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      4.0
      
      Amount of Environmental Fines or Penalties
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      4.0
      
      Discloses Health & Safety Violations
- ?
  
  ✔
  
  5.0
  
  Environmental Impacts [+]
  - ?
    
    ✔
    
    5.3
    
    Emissions [+]
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      7.5
      
      Greenhouse Gases [+]
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        8.0
        
        Quantitative Performance Metrics [+]
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        8.0
        
        Quantitative Performance Measures [+]
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        9.0
        
        Direct Emissions of Greenhouse Gases per Employee
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        7.0
        
        Indirect Emissions of Greenhouse Gases per Employee
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        8.0
        
        Total Emissions of Greenhouse Gases per $ Revenue
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        7.0
        
        Policies and Practices [+]
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        7.0
        
        Climate Change Policy Includes Quantifiable Targets
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Discloses Indirect Emissions of Greenhouse Gases
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Climate Change Policy Specifics
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reduction Initiatives - Transportation
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Discloses Direct Emissions of Greenhouse Gases
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        5.0
        
        Climate Change Policy Includes Stakeholder Involvement
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        5.0
        
        Enterprise Level Climate Change Policy
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        5.0
        
        Climate Change Policy Applies to All Operations
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        5.0
        
        Climate Change Policy Addresses Greenhouse Gases
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        5.0
        
        Environmental Policy Addresses Greenhouse Gases
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Percentage of Indirect Greenhouse Gas Emissions Balanced by Sequestration
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Percentage of Direct Greenhouse Gas Emissions Balanced by Carbon Offsets
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Normalized Indirect Emissions of CO2
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reduction Initiatives - Production Process
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Use of Carbon Sequestration
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Carbon Credits
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses CO2 Emissions at Non-US Facilities
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Percentage of Indirect Greenhouse Gas Emissions Balanced by Carbon Offsets
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Carbon Offsets
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Normalized Indirect Emissions of CO2
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Greenhouse Gas Emissions Quantitative Targets
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Normalized Direct Emissions of Greenhouse Gases
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Sale of Carbon Credits
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Indirect Emissions of CO2
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Greenhouse Gas Emissions at Non-US Facilities
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Climate Change Policy Includes Auditing
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Normalized Direct Emissions of CO2
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Total Sale of Carbon Credits
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Direct Emissions of CO2 Emissions
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Percentage of Direct Greenhouse Gas Emissions Balanced by Sequestration
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Independent Verification of Carbon Credits
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Climate Change Policy Includes 3rd-party Auditing
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      6.0
      
      Emissions [+]
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Take-back & Recycling Programs
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        e-Waste Recycling Initiatives
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Toxics Use Reduction Initiatives
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Emissions Reduction Targets
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Use of Key Performance Indicators to Monitor Emission Reductions
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Emission Reduction Processes
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        5.0
        
        Emissions Reduction Policy
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Initiatives to Reduce Spills
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      5.0
      
      Waste [+]
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Policies [+]
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Discloses Hazardous Waste Disposal Program Details
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Consumer Product Waste Management Program
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Business Waste Recycling Program
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Recycling Programs
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Packaging Waste Management Program
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Waste Reduction Initiatives
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Business Waste Management Program
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Packaging Waste Recycling Program
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Solid Waste Management Program
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Hazardous Waste Reduction Initiatives
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        6.0
        
        Discloses a Waste Management Program
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Production Waste Recycling Program
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Normalized Hazardous Waste Generation
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Production Waste Management Program
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Identity of its Primary Hazardous Wastes
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Emissions Reported to Toxics Release Inventory
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Chemical Waste Management Program
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Hazardous Waste Generation at Non-US Facilities
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses TRI-Equivalent Emissions at Non-US Facilities
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Hazardous Waste Generation
        
        ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Normalized TRI Emissions
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Spills and Other Pollution Controversies
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      4.0
      
      Policies and Practices [+]
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Water Pollution Reduction Initiatives
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Water Recycling Percentage
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Normalized Water Pollutant Emissions
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Waste Water Discharge Data
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      4.0
      
      Policies and Practices [+]
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses NOx Emissions
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Initiatives to Reduce Hazardous Air Pollutants
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses SOx/NOx Emissions
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses SOx/NOx Emissions at Non-US Facilities
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Normalized SOx Emissions
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Normalized SOx/NOx Emissions
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Normalized NMVOC Emissions
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses Normalized NOx Emissions
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses SOx Emissions
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses NMVOC Emissions
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Initiatives to Reduce Persistent Organic Pollutants
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Initiatives to Reduce Ozone-depleting Substances
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Initiatives to Reduce VOCs
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Initiatives to Reduce SOx or NOx
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Discloses NMVOC Emissions at Non-US Facilities
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Initiatives to Reduce Particulate Matter
      - ?
        
        ✔
        
        4.0
        
        Initiatives to Reduce Fluorinated Gases
  - ?
    
    ✔
    
    4.0
    
    Policies [+]
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      4.0
      
      Production Concentration
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      4.0
      
      Biodiversity Policy
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      4.0
      
      Biodiversity Restoration or Protection Initiatives
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      4.0
      
      Biodiversity Impact Reporting
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      4.0
      
      Biodiversity Management Processes
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      4.0
      
      Use of Key Peformance Indicators to Monitor Biodiversity Impact
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      4.0
      
      Biodiversity Targets
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      4.0
      
      Discloses a Biodiversity Program
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      4.0
      
      Evaluation of Environmental and Biodiversity Risks
    - ?
      
      ✔
      
      4.0
      
      Land Management Initiatives
- ?
  
  ✔
  
  5.0
  
  Transparency

Check prices...

Searching for
additional offers...

Ingredients

Water

•
?

✔

10
Ammonium Lauryl Sulfate

•
?

✔

10
Dimethicone

•
?

✔

10
(1-METHYLETHYL)BENZENESULFONIC Acid,
Sodium Salt

•
?

✔

8.0
Cocamide Monoethanolamine

•
?

✔

10
Cetyl Alcohol

•
?

✔

10
Wheat (Triticum Vulgare) Gluten

•
?

✔

10
Wheat Germ Oil

•
?

✔

10
Avena Sativa (oat) Peptide

•
?

✔

10
Mauritia Flexuosa Fruit Oil

•
?

✔

10
Acrylates Copolymer

•
?

✔

10
Cocamidopropyl Betaine

•
?

✔

8.0
Capryl Glycol

•
?

✔

10
Fragrance

•
?

✔

0
Phenoxyethanol

•
?

✔

8.0
Glycol Distearate

•
?

✔

10
Tetrasodium EDTA

•
?

✔

10
Guar Hydroxypropyltrimonium Chloride

•
?

✔

10
Polyquatemium 10

•
?

✔

10
Glycerin

•
?

✔

10
Mica

•
?

✔

8.0
Titanium Dioxide

•
?

✔

8.0
FD&C Yellow 6

•
?

✔

10
D&C Yellow 10

•
?

✔

10
Citric Acid

•
?

✔

10
Sodium Hydroxide

•
?

✔

8.0
See package label ingredients

About the company

Parent Company:

CVS Pharmacy, Inc

Parent Company:

CVS Caremark Corporation

Other Products made include:

after shave, after sun product, anti-aging cream, and anti-fungal treatment. 660 CVS products have GoodGuide ratings. See the list »

More about CVS »

Compare companies making personal care products »

Compare personal care brands »

Certifications and listings

This product is not included on any certification lists.

Not included on 8 possible lists - show

CVS Nourishing Moisture Shampoo

Buy Now

Top Alternatives

Ingredients

About the company

Certifications and listings

Comments