Buying Guide: The issues
The average U.S. consumer uses about 10 cosmetic products every day, including soap, shampoo, lotions, deodorants and fragrances. These products can contain hundreds of ingredients, and their regular use can result in chronic exposures to low levels of potential hazards. The most important issues associated with shampoos include:
- Health concerns — Shampoo ingredients can pose potential human health hazards. In most cases, a chemical that provides a shampoo with a desired hair care property may also exhibit hazard profiles that risk-averse consumers would prefer to avoid. In the worst cases, poor product stewardship results in some manufacturers formulating shampoos to include recognized carcinogens like phenolphthalein or butylated hydroxyanisole.
- Ingredient disclosure — Complete lists of shampoo ingredient lists are often unavailable, creating a significant barrier to assessing the safety of personal care products. Although companies are required to disclose the ingredients in personal care products, these lists rarely contain information about percent composition (needed to assess potential exposures) and often rely on generic terms like “fragrance,” which make it impossible to assess whether there are any problematic ingredients present.
- Contamination concerns — The Food and Drug Administration only requires cosmetic firms to list “intended” ingredients in products, which allows manufacturers to hide the presence of other ingredients from consumers. For example, shampoos that use sodium laureth sulfate as a foaming agent, are often contaminated with the recognized carcinogen 1,4-dioxane, a byproduct of a chemical processing technique called ethoxylation. Only after consumer organizations tested products have manufacturers committed to reformulate their shampoos to reduce levels of this shampoo ingredient. Similar concerns exist in products that contain formaldehyde-generating ingredients like DMDM, hydantoin or nitrosamine-generating ingredients like diethanolamine (DEA) and triethanolamine (TEA).
- Inadequate regulation — Personal care products are not subject to safety reviews by the FDA before they are put on the market, and the agency is frequently criticized for its lax approach to regulation. The European Union, for example, has banned the use of more than 1,000 substances in cosmetics; in contrast, the FDA has only prohibited the use of eight substances in cosmetics. There is widespread skepticism that the current regulatory system is sufficiently protective of human health.
Buying Guide: What to look for
Look for shampoos that are certified as sustainable by Cradle-to-Cradle or as compliant with the standards set by EcoLogo or the Natural Products Association for personal care products. Also keep an eye out for other certifications like the NSF “Made with Organic” and Quality Assurance International seals, which focus on ensuring that “organic” marketing claims are valid for an entire product rather than just a few constituents.
Products that contain no ingredients of health concern, or only ingredients of low health concern. Note that you may want to avoid even low concern ingredients if you want to avoid exposures to shampoo ingredients like monoethanolamine that could cause asthma.
Products that are minimally packaged with recyclable materials.
Scoring Personal Care and Household Chemical Products
GoodGuide counts the number of ingredients in each product that are categorized as low, medium or high health concern. We then factor in other negative information (such as regulatory restrictions) and any available positive information (such as third-party certifications) to assign product scores.
GoodGuide counts the number of ingredients in each product that are categorized as a low, medium or high health concern. We then factor in other negative information (such as regulatory restrictions) and any available positive information (such as third-party certifications) to assign product scores.
To rate a personal care or household chemical product on Health, GoodGuide utilizes the following attributes:
- A health hazard score based on the number of product ingredients that are categorized as low, medium or high health concern.
- Indicators that the product exhibits other negative aspects (e.g., does the product contain ingredients that have been banned or subjected to regulatory restrictions).
- Indicators that the product is among the best on the market in its category (e.g., has the product been certified as safe or healthy by a credible third-party).
- Indicators of data gaps that preclude evaluation of the product (e.g., no or inadequate disclosure of product ingredients).
Product-level data on environmental performance are generally unavailable for personal care and household chemical products, so GoodGuide relies on company-level environmental scores to characterize the performance of a product on this dimension.